Many people ask from us that what should be the response to following Questions and Allegation.
First Set of Question
By Some Salafi* Brothers (The misguided and ignorant Salafis, not by all salafis) who do following Allegations on Tablighi Jamaat.
1.The founder of this Jamaa’ah was a grave worshipper.(Nauzubillah)
2. Tablighi Jamaat are Quboori the grave Worshipper (Nauzubillah)
3. Tablighi Jamaat teaches Shirk (Nauzubillah)
Markaz Nizamuddin stand is very clear and well known for these allegation i.e to do Sabr and to pray for Hidayat of the these people.
My response as blogger in my personal capacity.
1. Tell the allegation doer, "Is he/she ready to face consequences of allegation in Qiyamah. It is not that he take it back but he should have to make istighfar,and seeking pardon from the slaves of Allah and may be recitation of Kalima again to be Muslim again. What they have said is indeed something extremely grave without knowledge.
Second Set of Question
By Some other Salafi Brothers (Who have difference of opinion with mainstream Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat but no one should claim them misguided.)
4. The founder of this Jamaa’ah was a follower of the Fiqh of Imam Abu Haneefa. As following a Mazhab is wrong .so he was not from Ahle sunnat.
(Yes he followed Fiqh of Imam Abu Haneefa as he was ahle sunnat wal jamaat. And following one of four Imam is established way of Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat Scholar. For detail click here.)
5. The founder of this Jamaa’ah believed in taking Waseela of prophet sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam after his death.So he is not Ahle Sunnat.
(Yes he believed in it as he was ahle sunnat wal jamaat. And there is proof from Sound Sunnah for it and a great Majority of Salafus Salehin Scholars believed in it.) For detail click here.)
6.The founder of this Jamaa’ah believed in special life of prophet sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam after his death.So he is not Ahle Sunnat.
(Yes he believed in it as he was ahle sunnat wal jamaat. And there is proof from Quran and Sound Sunnah for it and a great Majority of Salafus Salehin Scholars believed in it.) For detail click here.)
7. The founder of this Jamaa’ah was a soofee.So he is not Ahle Sunnat.
(Tasawwuf is a science to achieve Ihsan and Tazkiya. Yes he was in the field of Ihsan o Tazkiya (Tasawwuf) as he was from ahle sunnat wal jamaat. And there is proof from Quran and Sound Sunnah for Tasawwuf and a great Majority of Salafus Salehin Scholars believed in it.) For detail click here.)
Some people are infamous for doing wrong on the name of Tasawwuf but Tablighi Jamaat is free from wrong form of tasawwuf and all muslims should do effort to purify tasawwuf as it is very good science to achieve akhlaq, ikhlas, zuhad, sabr, qinayat and all these qualities are desired in Quran and Hadith.
8. The founder of this Jamaa’ah believed in Kashf and Karamat e Aulia.
(Yes he believed in karamat and Kash as he was ahle sunnat wal jamaat.Even Ibn Taimiyyah believed in Kashf and Karamat For detail click here.)
9. The founder of this Jamaa’ah was an Ashari-Maturidi in Aqeedah. As being Ashari- Maturidi is wrong .so he was not from Ahle sunnat.
(This question is related with the explanation (if any) for attributes of Allah.The answer will depend on what do you mean by being Ashari. The Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat has a middle path and following is the established way of Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat Scholar.
For detail read this book.)
https://ia601506.us.archive.org/26/items/SalafiAshariAqeedahDifference/salafi%20ashari%20aqeedah%20difference.pdf
To continue ..........................................
Summary of Article
Alahamdulillah for the Tabligh Jamaat. Tabligh Jamaat is one of the Jamaat working for Islam. It is 100% sure that most of the allegations have mentioned is 100% wrong. People think they can say any lies about Tabligh Jamaat because the scholars of Tabligh will not reply them back or come for debate for these accusations. The effort is clear as the day to witness and you will not find any grave worshipers amongst them if you travel east and west with them. Also their scholars are afraid of themselves than others. Because this was the condition of Salaf Salihoon. They feared themselves to be in danger while having a faith as strong as mountains, they thought others to be good. Now these lies are created by those who thinks just the opposite. They did not even spend a day with them and they cook these lies. May Allah guide them and forgive them.
I myself have spent some of my time in the Path of Allah and it did help me Alhamdulillah.. Shaikh Umar Palanpoori (r.a) once said to Arabs, In India we are called as Wahhabis, Arabs call us as Sufis. We have none but Allah. At personal level you will witness Allah's help and it's path to build Yaqeen in Allah and hereafter. It's a path to forsake Shirk and build Tauheed. Even for a small matter, you become one who turns to Allah before you turn to anyone else. Shaikh Muhammad Ilyas (r.a) is far away from what you have accused. His Tarteeb (system) in the field of Da'wa is accepted because that have closer to the efforts of our beloved Prophet (s.a.w) than many other efforts we see nowadays. Be it, debates, lectures, CDs, TV Shows etc etc.
Most of the things are well explained in the Arab's personal site http://www.binatiih.com (There is no official website/office or any registered things in the name of TJ). I also have put some of the videos of Arabs scholars also here http://www.youtube.com/ismaileliat
(Summary Taken with some edition from http://www.youtube.com/ismaileliat with Jazakallah o Khair
First Set of Question
By Some Salafi* Brothers (The misguided and ignorant Salafis, not by all salafis) who do following Allegations on Tablighi Jamaat.
1.The founder of this Jamaa’ah was a grave worshipper.(Nauzubillah)
2. Tablighi Jamaat are Quboori the grave Worshipper (Nauzubillah)
3. Tablighi Jamaat teaches Shirk (Nauzubillah)
Markaz Nizamuddin stand is very clear and well known for these allegation i.e to do Sabr and to pray for Hidayat of the these people.
My response as blogger in my personal capacity.
1. Tell the allegation doer, "Is he/she ready to face consequences of allegation in Qiyamah. It is not that he take it back but he should have to make istighfar,and seeking pardon from the slaves of Allah and may be recitation of Kalima again to be Muslim again. What they have said is indeed something extremely grave without knowledge.
Second Set of Question
By Some other Salafi Brothers (Who have difference of opinion with mainstream Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat but no one should claim them misguided.)
4. The founder of this Jamaa’ah was a follower of the Fiqh of Imam Abu Haneefa. As following a Mazhab is wrong .so he was not from Ahle sunnat.
(Yes he followed Fiqh of Imam Abu Haneefa as he was ahle sunnat wal jamaat. And following one of four Imam is established way of Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat Scholar. For detail click here.)
5. The founder of this Jamaa’ah believed in taking Waseela of prophet sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam after his death.So he is not Ahle Sunnat.
(Yes he believed in it as he was ahle sunnat wal jamaat. And there is proof from Sound Sunnah for it and a great Majority of Salafus Salehin Scholars believed in it.) For detail click here.)
6.The founder of this Jamaa’ah believed in special life of prophet sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam after his death.So he is not Ahle Sunnat.
(Yes he believed in it as he was ahle sunnat wal jamaat. And there is proof from Quran and Sound Sunnah for it and a great Majority of Salafus Salehin Scholars believed in it.) For detail click here.)
7. The founder of this Jamaa’ah was a soofee.So he is not Ahle Sunnat.
(Tasawwuf is a science to achieve Ihsan and Tazkiya. Yes he was in the field of Ihsan o Tazkiya (Tasawwuf) as he was from ahle sunnat wal jamaat. And there is proof from Quran and Sound Sunnah for Tasawwuf and a great Majority of Salafus Salehin Scholars believed in it.) For detail click here.)
Some people are infamous for doing wrong on the name of Tasawwuf but Tablighi Jamaat is free from wrong form of tasawwuf and all muslims should do effort to purify tasawwuf as it is very good science to achieve akhlaq, ikhlas, zuhad, sabr, qinayat and all these qualities are desired in Quran and Hadith.
8. The founder of this Jamaa’ah believed in Kashf and Karamat e Aulia.
(Yes he believed in karamat and Kash as he was ahle sunnat wal jamaat.Even Ibn Taimiyyah believed in Kashf and Karamat For detail click here.)
9. The founder of this Jamaa’ah was an Ashari-Maturidi in Aqeedah. As being Ashari- Maturidi is wrong .so he was not from Ahle sunnat.
(This question is related with the explanation (if any) for attributes of Allah.The answer will depend on what do you mean by being Ashari. The Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat has a middle path and following is the established way of Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat Scholar.
For Attributes for Allah like Waj (Face) Yad (Hand) The best and most appriporiate is manahaj of Salaf that it should be believed without Taweel means only this much to be told that Attribute yad, waj, istiwa alal arsh are proven but it reallity/kifayah is unknown, It is Only known to Allah.This was position of Salaf.
Later on some sect came into existence and started telling meaning of these words in a way that warranted the understanding that Allah must have a body like Human/Likened Allah to creastion (Nauzubillah)
Thats why Later Islamic Scholars did explained meaning in a way that is appropriate and donot bring any disrepute to Allah. So it is not appropriate labeled those later scholars as deviant (As they used this only to quell the Fitnah of Deviated Mushabiah Sect)
For detail read this book.)
https://ia601506.us.archive.org/26/items/SalafiAshariAqeedahDifference/salafi%20ashari%20aqeedah%20difference.pdf
To continue ..........................................
Summary of Article
Alahamdulillah for the Tabligh Jamaat. Tabligh Jamaat is one of the Jamaat working for Islam. It is 100% sure that most of the allegations have mentioned is 100% wrong. People think they can say any lies about Tabligh Jamaat because the scholars of Tabligh will not reply them back or come for debate for these accusations. The effort is clear as the day to witness and you will not find any grave worshipers amongst them if you travel east and west with them. Also their scholars are afraid of themselves than others. Because this was the condition of Salaf Salihoon. They feared themselves to be in danger while having a faith as strong as mountains, they thought others to be good. Now these lies are created by those who thinks just the opposite. They did not even spend a day with them and they cook these lies. May Allah guide them and forgive them.
I myself have spent some of my time in the Path of Allah and it did help me Alhamdulillah.. Shaikh Umar Palanpoori (r.a) once said to Arabs, In India we are called as Wahhabis, Arabs call us as Sufis. We have none but Allah. At personal level you will witness Allah's help and it's path to build Yaqeen in Allah and hereafter. It's a path to forsake Shirk and build Tauheed. Even for a small matter, you become one who turns to Allah before you turn to anyone else. Shaikh Muhammad Ilyas (r.a) is far away from what you have accused. His Tarteeb (system) in the field of Da'wa is accepted because that have closer to the efforts of our beloved Prophet (s.a.w) than many other efforts we see nowadays. Be it, debates, lectures, CDs, TV Shows etc etc.
Most of the things are well explained in the Arab's personal site http://www.binatiih.com (There is no official website/office or any registered things in the name of TJ). I also have put some of the videos of Arabs scholars also here http://www.youtube.com/ismaileliat
(Summary Taken with some edition from http://www.youtube.com/ismaileliat with Jazakallah o Khair
